Pool Resurfacing vs Replastering – Which is the Better Option?

Robert Wimberly

pool resurfacing vs replastering

If you have a pool at home that needs regular upkeep, gaining an understanding of the distinction between pool resurfacing and replastering is of utmost importance. But are you familiar with the know-how that sets these two procedures apart?

This article compares the processes of pool resurfacing vs replastering by exploring their differences in materials, processes, and benefits to help you make informed decisions about the most suitable option for your pool maintenance needs.

Pool Resurfacing Replastering
Application Adding a new layer without removing the old plaster Involves removing the damaged plaster for a new layer
Reparation Discoloration, chalking, or minor stains Major cracks, damages, and large stains
Lastingness Short-term Long-term (around 10 – 20 years)
Aesthetics Restored Improved
Labor + material costs More affordable Higher

What is Pool Resurfacing and Replastering?


Much like any other things, pools also undergo wear and tear over time, necessitating upkeep. The presence of flaws on a pool’s surface compromises its general health and aesthetic appeal and offers significant safety risks for both pool owners and swimmers.

Fortunately, several approaches may be used to deal with this kind of problem. The two most popular procedures, pool resurfacing, and pool replastering, significantly and positively influence the before and after appearance of the damaged surface of your pool.

1. Pool resurfacing


In this procedure, a fresh material layer is directly applied to the current pool surface, paying close attention to any damaged regions. The new layer effectively produces a flawless pool refinish, restoring the afflicted areas’ structural integrity as well as their aesthetics.

The new layer of material applied over existing plaster is typically intended to conceal cosmetic blemishes on the pool surface. This includes addressing issues like discoloration, staining, or the development of a chalky residue.

Resurfacing options include the following:

  • Plaster Finishes – They provide a smooth look and color choices. Still, they may require more upkeep and have a shorter lifespan compared to other options.
  • Aggregate Finishes – These textured finishes are popular choices for resurfacing swimming pools because they are resistant to chemicals and resilient to hard use, making them long-lasting.
  • Tile and Stone – This choice entails higher pool resurfacing cost compared to other options and might not be feasible for the complete pool surface due to financial considerations and installation constraints.

2. Pool replastering


Replastering a pool, which is utilized on occasion when the surface of the pool has sustained severe damage, is considered a more thorough approach than pool resurfacing.

It entails removing the old plaster layer and completely replacing it with a new one.

The pool replaster process is rather the least chosen option among homeowners due to its relatively high cost; however, this option assures you that it offers an extended pool lifespan, improved aesthetics, and a safe swimming experience for you and your loved ones.

Replastering options are as follows:

  • Standard Plaster – The surface of the pool is covered with a fresh coating of classic plaster mix in this straightforward replastering method, producing a sleek and neat result.
  • Aggregate Replaster – These added materials make the surface sturdier and resistant to damaging agents, leading to less frequent repairs and maintenance and making it a practical choice for lasting pool quality.

Factors to Consider

When deciding whether to pool resurface or replaster, there are several factors to consider:

1. Total cost


The repair cost is the primary consideration when choosing between pool resurfacing and replastering.

Resurfacing a concrete pool costs approximately $650 per 100 square feet, while replastering ranges from $350 to $1200.

Furthermore, painting your pool can cost around $100 for 100 square feet. And if you hire a service to drain the pool before replastering, it could cost you about $400 – $500 for the task, plus cleaning.

Indeed, costs for both options can significantly vary due to pool type, size, surface condition, repairs needed, and chosen finish.

2. Appearance:


Deciding between pool resurfacing and pool replastering depends on your desired outcome.

Opting to revamp your pool? Then pool replastering is the best way to go, as it provides a total pool transformation. This method includes updating tiles, the pool deck, plumbing, and finishes, giving your pool a fresh and modern look.

On the other hand, if your goal is to rectify minor imperfections and retain your pool’s current look, pool resurfacing is a more practical option. This approach concentrates solely on replacing the compromised pool surface rather than a complete overhaul.

3. Durability


Compared to replastering, pool resurfacing generally offers less durability.

Resurfacing, which only adds a new layer to damaged surfaces, might miss underlying flaws and make other overlooked components more susceptible to damage over time.

The durability of pool resurfacing hinges significantly on the caliber of materials used and upkeep. For instance, aggregate finishes outlast standard plasters due to their resilience against chemicals and frequent usage, ensuring a longer-lasting surface.

Meanwhile, replastering guarantees more durability by thoroughly addressing all possible problems through an extensive pool overhaul. This effectively resets the pool’s lifespan, increasing both the pool’s longevity and resiliency to damageable factors.

Best Situations for Each Option


Here are some best situations where each option may be more suitable:

Pool Resurfacing:

Worn Plaster Surface: Resurfacing is suitable when the existing plaster surface is worn, faded, or discolored but still structurally sound. It can help restore the smoothness and appearance of the pool.

Pool Replastering:

Severely Damaged Surface: The option to refinish a pool using replastering is done if your pool has extensive damage, such as cracks, chips, or etching, resurfacing is often the preferred choice.


Whatever pool you have at home, may that be a luxury or an inground pool, the best time of year to replaster pool or resurface it is now rather than later. You can only enjoy your swimming experience when your pool is safe and aesthetically pleasing.

Remember, the answer on which is a better pool fix between pool resurfacing vs replastering relies on your needs, budget, and preferences. Given this, explore your choices and promptly restore your pool for a fun swimming experience for you and your loved ones.

5/5 - (2 votes)